Noah Brier has some thoughts on Facebook and it has prompted me to speak of mine.
In my opinion Facebook is Yet Another Social Network whose only redeeming value has been its college-roots birth. Of all the social networks I belong to, Facebook has by far the highest ratio of “real people.” People I have been to school with, worked with and met in the flesh. At first this made it more interesting than other social networks which consisted of many good friends but many of whom I have never met “in the flesh.”
After awhile though, probably around the 50th Daily Dragon and 60th Fortune Cookie request, I realised there was a reason I hadn’t stayed in contact with these people. They aren’t bad people, they aren’t even dull or boring people, and neither am I. We just went our separate ways after school or work and, well, went our separate ways. Trying to force us all back together again because we shared school years has short-term value. Some fun catch-up stories, some not so fun news (”she died”, “he killed himself” etc.) and then a 60 cycle hum of silence as you realise you have nothing left to talk about.
It shouldn’t take a social network site to stay in touch with friends. If it does then you might want to reconsider the word “friend.”
It is powerful though. Many people find school reunions important and fascinating. They put value in catching up and comparing success. I’m not one of those people so Facebook isn’t for me.
Still, I persist in dissecting it.
It offers photos. Already got that in Flickr, and a much more powerful system at that. It offers “status updates”, which Twitter or Pownce does better. You can email friends. Except they aren’t really emails, you just get a “Bob sent you a message, click here to spend 5 minutes logging in and reading it on Facebook.” I find that very annoying. Why email me through Facebook and force me to visit Facebook when you can just email me on my email address? Or IM me. Please.
And it offers those mini-apps, of which I have found none of real use. Cute, fun, kitten-in-a-jar kind of thing. Folks, I am 27, I have an attention span longer than a mini-skirt, please send me something interesting.
This is my hope and my belief; people will get bored with Facebook and move on.