Can someone please explain the fascination with .Mac?
I am a MacBook Pro user and their hardware pleases me. I think Mac OS X is a fine operating system and that iWork beats Microsoft Office for 90% of your word processing, spreadsheet and presentation needs. iTunes is my daily media player and the iTunes Music Store is the best out there.
But iLife and .Mac leave me cold. I will leave the deficiencies of iLife for another day but .Mac perplexes me. I know Khoi Vinh and many others, including a very good friend who converted me to the Mac Way, want .Mac to Just Work. To be as wholly pleasing as using other Apple products.
Yet .Mac has never even shown a glimmer of wholeness. It seems to mainly only work with Apple produced software, you get some online space, a .Mac email address (because you need yet another email address folks) and some of the iLife products can publish to it in some rather random and inconsistent way (iPhoto seems to lead the charge there.) And you get some kind of backup tool.
Apparently I can get a nice seamless online address book sync. with my iPhone but since I don’t use my MacBook Pro to store my address book it doesn’t work. I have to run software on my MacBook Pro to get my iPhone to sync. with an online address book? 1995 flashback!
I don’t use Mail.app or iPhoto either so there goes half of the worth of .Mac.
And it costs $99.95 every year.
Does it have an API or even RSS? Does it work with Flickr, Delicious, Facebook or any other site at all? I see it reinvents a Group system which doesn’t seem to do much at all.
For normal folk does it backup everything on my Mac without me having to worry? The answer to that would be no because 10GB isn’t going to cut it for even average computer users with their documents, email, photos, videos and music. Can I buy more than 10GB?
This is typical Apple though and it isn’t their specialty. They aren’t an online company, yet. Even the iTunes Music Store is a bit of a bastardised offshoot of the web.
I wouldn’t look to Apple to provide a complete online service just yet. They are working on consumer products and doing a very good job with that. They haven’t yet got a handle on this world wide web thing. When Jobs does wake up one morning and decide it is time to start focusing on it, then, and only then, will I start hoping for more from .Mac.